What Causes Sundowning? Frustration or Chemistry?
In "SUNDOWNING SYNDROME," people with dementia show high levels of anxiety, agitation, overactivity and delirium. It typically occurs in late afternoon and evening, before their normal time to go to bed. Learn how brain biology explains “sundowning.” COLUMBUS, Ohio – Valuable research provides the best evidence to date that the late-day anxiety and agitation sometimes seen in older institutionalized adults, especially those with dementia, has a biological basis in the brain. The findings could help explain “sundowning,” a syndrome in which older adults show high levels of anxiety, agitation, general activity and delirium in late afternoon and evening, before they would normally go to bed.
What's Going On in the Brain During Sundowning?
“It’s a big problem for caregivers. Patients can get aggressive and very disruptive,” said Tracy Bedrosian, lead author of the study and a doctoral student in neuroscience at Ohio State University. “There have been a few clinical studies documenting sundowning, but until now there hasn’t been research in animals to see what’s going on in the brain to explain this.”
More Activity
The important study found that aged mice showed significantly more activity and more anxiety-like behaviors in the hours before they would normally sleep when compared to middle-aged mice – just like sundowning in humans. In these aged mice, the researchers found changes in parts of their brain associated with attention, emotions, and arousal, all of which could be associated with the behavior seen in sundowning. In addition, mice that were genetically engineered to have an Alzheimer’s-like disease also showed more anxiety before sleep than did other mice.
Biological Basis
“Some people have argued that sundowning could be explained just by a buildup of frustration of older people who couldn’t communicate their needs over the course of the day, or by other factors,” said Randy Nelson, co-author of the study and professor of neuroscience and psychology at Ohio State. “But our findings suggest there is a real phenomenon going on here that has a biological basis.” The study appears in the online Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. In the first experiment, researchers compared middle-aged adult mice (7 months old) with aged mice (29 months old) that would resemble humans in their 80s. Results showed that the aged mice were significantly more active than middle-aged mice in the two to three hours before they would normally go to sleep. “The middle-aged mice had a distinct pattern of activity, with three peaks of activity during their waking hours,” Bedrosian said. “But the aged mice had a flattened rhythm in which they showed the same level of activity throughout their active period.”
Evenings & Sundowning
That means that in the evening, when the middle aged mice would slow down compared to their peak activity levels, the aged mice kept going. The mice were also tested for anxiety-like behaviors at two different times during their waking hours. The mice were placed in a maze where they were allowed to explore open areas – which are more anxiety-producing – or hide in enclosed areas. The middle-aged mice showed consistent levels of anxiety at both times of the day. However, the aged mice showed more anxiety when tested soon before they would have gone to sleep, which is consistent with sundowning, Bedrosian said.
The Cholinergic System & Circadian Changes
There were also differences in the brains of the aged mice when compared to the middle aged mice. The researchers looked specifically at the cholinergic system, because loss of function in that system is associated with dementia and many of the circadian changes associated with aging. Findings in aged mice showed greater expression of a certain enzyme – acetylcholinesterase – before sleep than earlier in the day. High levels of this enzyme are associated with anxiety and agitation. However, in the middle-aged mice, there were no time-of-day differences in the expression of this enzyme. Nelson noted that drugs used to control levels of acetylcholinesterase are sometimes used on dementia patients, although there has been no research evidence that it actually had an effect on sundowning.
“These drugs were prescribed for other purposes, but it also seemed to calm patients down. Now we have some evidence on why it works,” Nelson said.
Anxiety, Agitation & Proteins
The researchers also found differences in expression of two other proteins in the brains of the aged mice that are also associated with behavioral disturbances. “All of these results converge to suggest there are changes in the cholinergic systems of aged mice that may be contributing to the anxiety and agitation symptoms that we documented,” Bedrosian said. In another experiment, the researchers used mice that were genetically engineered to develop Alzheimer’s-like disease in their brain. They were compared, at nine months of age, to similar wild-type mice of the same age. The Alzheimer’s-like mice showed more anxiety-type behaviors when tested before they would normally sleep than they did when tested earlier in their waking period. That is consistent with sundowning in humans, the researchers said. However, the wild-type mice showed no differences in anxiety levels based on the time of day they were tested. Nelson said one of the theories about sundowning is that it is tied to disruptions that often occur in the biological clocks of older people, where their sleep-wake cycles are fragmented. To test this theory, the researchers also treated the aged mice with melatonin for four weeks in order to help consolidate their circadian rhythms. However, this treatment did not work to reduce anxiety issues in the mice. Nelson said melatonin alone may not work because it doesn’t deal with the disruptions in the cholinergic system that was identified in this study. “We need to study whether treating cholinergic dysfunction alone or in combination with melatonin treatment will help deal with sundowning symptoms,” he said.
SOURCE: The Ohio State University